Issue 416: Scope note of E34

Starting Date: 
2019-04-10
Working Group: 
3
Status: 
Done
Closing Date: 
2019-06-12
Background: 

Posted by martin on 10/4/2019

Dear All,

The current scope not of E34 include a reference to the deprecated E84:

OLD

E34 Inscription

Subclass of:         E33 Linguistic Object

E37 Mark

 

Scope note:         This class comprises recognisable, short texts attached to instances of E24 Physical Man-Made Thing.

 

The transcription of the text can be documented in a note by P3 has note: E62 String. The alphabet used can be documented by P2 has type: E55 Type. This class does not intend to describe the idiosyncratic characteristics of an individual physical embodiment of an inscription, but the underlying prototype. The physical embodiment is modelled in the CRM as E24 Physical Man-Made Thing.

The relationship of a physical copy of a book to the text it contains is modelled using E84 Information Carrier. P128 carries (is carried by): E33 Linguistic Object.

 

Examples:          

§  “keep off the grass” on a sign stuck in the lawn of the quad of Balliol College

§  The text published in Corpus Inscriptionum Latinarum V 895

§  Kilroy was here

In First Order Logic:

                           E34(x) ⊃ E33(x)

                           E34(x) ⊃ E37(x)

NEW:

Replace:

The relationship of a physical copy of a book to the text it contains is modelled using E84 Information Carrier. P128 carries (is carried by): E33 Linguistic Object.

by:

The relationship of a physical copy of a book to the text it contains is modelled using E22 Man-Made Object. P128 carries (is carried by): E33 Linguistic Object.
 

 

Current Proposal: 

Posted by  Øyvind Eide, Achille Felicetti, Richard Light ,George Bruseker, Stephen Stead ,Christian-Emil Smith Ore, Athanasios Velios, Daria Hookk  on 11/4/2019

YES

 

Posted by  Mark Mudge, Robert Sanderson, Christos Papatheodorou      on 12/4/2019

YES

Posted by Melanie Roche on 23/4/2019

I vote yes.

Outcome: 

In the 44th joint meeting of the CIDOC CRM SIG and ISO/TC46/SC4/WG9; 37th FRBR - CIDOC CRM Harmonization meeting, the sig corroborated the result of the e-vote on the proposal by MD to edit the scope note for E34 Inscription, to avoid mention of deprecated class, E84 Information Carrier in it. The proposed change was unanimously accepted (12 sig members voted). Editing involved changing label of E22 Man-Made Object to E22 Human Made Object, according to decisions taken for Issue 370. The scope note of E34 was changed. The issue is closed

Paris, June 2019