The following discussion list is slightly modified
from that of Dublin Core. I have added a column "Identifier".
All mails to the discussion list should be sent to "crm-sig",
with subject = Re:<"Identifier">, nothing else. E.g: "subject:
Re:BIRTHPLACE" (or click on the respective identifier). This
will cause a natural order in the mail list archive. We shall
try to maintain the summaries of background, proposal and
outcome on this page up-to-date. The latest stage of discussion
and individual contributions will all be kept on the mailing
list archive. The purpose of this discussion list is not only
to reach agreement, but also to acquire an understanding of
problems associated with comprehension and application of
the CRM and its associated documentation. The input gathered
here will be a base to improve all parts of the documentation
of the CRM.
ID |
Title |
Working Group |
Status |
Closing Date |
| 1 |
How to Model Collections.... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-21 |
| 2 |
Make the scope note for Actor more explicit.... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-21 |
| 3 |
How to model life stages of natural
history specimens .... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-02 |
| 4 |
How to model extended topological operators.... |
1 |
done | 2001-10-18 |
| 5 |
How to model sound and multi-media objects.... |
1 |
done | 2001-10-18 |
| 6 |
How to model databases.... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-22 |
| 7 |
How to model relation between physical carrier and conceptual objects.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-02 |
| 8 |
Do physical feature and its decomposition need to be more rigidly defined?.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-05 |
| 9 |
How to model certainty and belief (scope and method).... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-05 |
| 10 |
Revise position of E27 Site.... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-21 |
| 11 |
How to document archaeological inference chains.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-05 |
| 12 |
How to model change of classifications (comprehension).... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-22 |
| 13 |
Is inception distinct from creation?.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-05 |
| 14 |
How to model 'subjects'.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-02 |
| 15 |
Is title different from appellation?.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-05 |
| 16 |
Which terminology should we use?.... |
3 |
done | 2002-10-22 |
| 17 |
How to visually distinguish examples drawn from subclasses within scope notes of a superclas.... |
1 |
done | 2001-10-18 |
| 18 |
Should there be a new name for the CRM?.... |
SIG |
done | 2003-10-7 |
| 19 |
How is the CRM going to be used ?.... |
2 |
done | 2003-03-25 |
| 20 |
How to model legal items.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-05 |
| 21 |
How to model membership entity, with temporal properties.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-02 |
| 22 |
How to deal with implementation guidelines.... |
4 |
done | 2003-10-07 |
| 23 |
Where does temporal validity fit in with short cuts and indirection?.... |
4 |
done | 2003-10-7 |
| 24 |
Review of production/creation.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-05 |
| 25 |
How to model a physical documents class (e.g. books).... |
1 |
done | 2001-10-18 |
| 26 |
How to model handling of process phases.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-05 |
| 27 |
Definition of the minimum scope for standardisation.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-05 |
| 28 |
How to organize outreach: collaboration, teaching and training, transfer of know-how.... |
4 |
done | 2003-10-7 |
| 29 |
How to model a person's birthplace.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-05 |
| 30 |
How to model a person's nationality.... |
1 |
done | 2001-10-18 |
| 31 |
How to model an actor's "active place".... |
1 |
done | 2001-10-18 |
| 32 |
How to model the depiction of a group.... |
1 |
done | 2001-10-18 |
| 33 |
How to model the depiction of a place.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-05 |
| 34 |
How to model sequences of events (temporal or spatial).... |
1 |
done | 2001-10-18 |
| 35 |
Guidance for museums etc. to distinguish between titles and other appellations.... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-22 |
| 36 |
How to model sequences of physical and conceptual objects.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 37 |
Transforming activity terms into gerunds where possible.... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-21 |
| 38 |
Delete Gender.... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-22 |
| 39 |
Creation of test data set for validating CRM compliance.... |
2 |
done | 2003-10-7 |
| 40 |
Physical features should have location.... |
1 |
done | 2001-10-18 |
| 41 |
Missing motivation for Man-Made Object.... |
1 |
done | 2001-10-18 |
| 42 |
Technique Application should be subproperty of "took into account".... |
1 |
done | 2001-10-18 |
| 43 |
Scope Notes for Properties.... |
3 |
done | 2002-10-22 |
| 44 |
Modeling States.... |
4 |
proposed | In Progress |
| 45 |
Causal relation between events.... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-22 |
| 46 |
Explanation about referring to use of materials in events and procedures.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-05 |
| 47 |
Use of kinds of objects.... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-22 |
| 48 |
Use of materials in events.... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-22 |
| 49 |
How to describe the technique that connects parts.... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-22 |
| 50 |
Use of the has type property.... |
3 |
done | 2002-10-22 |
| 51 |
Mappings may depend on object type.... |
4 |
done | 2003-10-7 |
| 52 |
Where does an instance of a multimedia object appear in the CRM.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 53 |
How to model digital surrogates.... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-22 |
| 54 |
Create a list of FAQs .... |
4 |
proposed | In Progress |
| 55 |
Difference between museum and library information .... |
4 |
done | 2003-10-7 |
| 56 |
Objects which are typical for a class .... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-02 |
| 57 |
Effort to teach use of the CRM .... |
4 |
done | 2004-04-21 |
| 58 |
How to organize the translation of the model.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 59 |
How to name the standard .... |
4 |
done | 2003-03-25 |
| 60 |
Identify new communities for collaboration .... |
4 |
done | 2003-10-7 |
| 61 |
Do we need a property "is copy of" ? .... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-02 |
| 62 |
Do we need an Actor Appellation entity? .... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 63 |
Does the Appellation need a value property? .... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-21 |
| 64 |
The definition of Number is too narrow .... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-21 |
| 65 |
Implementation guidelines for compounds .... |
4 |
done | 2003-10-7 |
| 66 |
Define exclusivity between CIDOC CRM entities .... |
1 |
done | 2001-10-18 |
| 67 |
How to model birth of living beings in general .... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-02 |
| 68 |
How to model isA relations between types .... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-22 |
| 69 |
Spatiotemporal overlaps of periods .... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 70 |
Relationship between P15 took into account and P17 was motivation for .... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 71 |
Guidance to distinguish between titles and other appellations .... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-21 |
| 72 |
Scope note of Modification .... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 73 |
Scope and Name of Existence.... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-21 |
| 74 |
Collections have no owner .... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-22 |
| 75 |
Rename E72 Stuff .... |
1 |
done | 2002-02-21 |
| 76 |
Contemporary Naming Procedure.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-02 |
| 77 |
Identification Procedure.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-02 |
| 78 |
P15 took into account to become a sub-property of P12 occurred in the presence of .... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 79 |
Change Property Name P17 was motivation for to was motivated by.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 80 |
Change range of P18 motivated the creation of .... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 81 |
Numbering of Properties.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-04 |
| 82 |
Review the range for P24 transferred title of .... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 83 |
P51 through to P55 should move from physical object to physical stuff.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 84 |
Consistency of P60 is member of and P107 had member .... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-02 |
| 85 |
Physical Carriers and Properties.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-02 |
| 86 |
P66 refers to concept is redundant.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-02 |
| 87 |
Ownership and Legal Rights.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-05 |
| 88 |
Rename Properties P81 at least covering and P82 at most within.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 89 |
P85 consists of is redundant.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 90 |
Scope Notes of E52.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 91 |
P72 has language is redundant.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 92 |
Declare all disjoint classes.... |
3 |
done | 2002-10-22 |
| 93 |
Also Represented By.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 94 |
Position of E72 Legal Object.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 95 |
P12 occurred in the presence of.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 96 |
Use of S/W tools.... |
1 |
done | 2002-07-03 |
| 97 |
Scope note for E17.... |
3 |
done | 2002-10-23 |
| 98 |
Physical Object exhibits general features.... |
4 |
done | 2003-10-7 |
| 99 |
Birth of non-humans.... |
4 |
done | 2003-10-08 |
| 100 |
Scope note of E33 Linguistic Object.... |
3 |
done | 2002-10-23 |
| 101 |
Scope Note for E73 to contain Multimedia Objects.... |
3 |
done | 2002-10-23 |
| 102 |
Scope note for Exx Actor Appellation.... |
3 |
done | 2002-10-23 |
| 103 |
Scope note for E42.... |
3 |
done | 2002-10-24 |
| 104 |
P77 consists of is redundant.... |
1 |
done | 2002-10-22 |
| 105 |
E67 Birth with multiple off springs.... |
3 |
done | 2002-10-24 |
| 106 |
P105 right held by .... |
1 |
done | 2002-10-23 |
| 107 |
P33 subproperty of P12.... |
1 |
done | 2002-10-23 |
| 108 |
Property needed for Actor
Appellation.... |
1 |
done | 2002-10-23 |
| 109 |
Declare "necessary" and "dependent" properties.... |
3 |
done | 2002-10-22 |
| 110 |
P109 is curated by (curates).... |
3 |
done | 2002-10-24 |
| 111 |
Add the crm scope definition, intended scope, to the final document .... |
3 |
done | 2002-10-24 |
| 112 |
Consistency of presence and participation.... |
1 |
done | 2002-10-23 |
| 115 |
Right & Legal Object.... |
3 |
done | 2002-10-24 |
| 116 |
The new CIDOC CRM web site .... |
4 |
done | 2003-10-7 |
| 117 |
For P62, property P62.1 mode of depiction is missing.... |
1 |
done | 2002-10-22 |
| 118 |
P30 transferred custody not to be a sub property of P12 occurred in the presence of.... |
1 |
done | 2002-10-22 |
| 120 |
Naming rules for properties.... |
3 |
done | 2002-10-22 |
| 121 |
E12 Production Event.... |
3 |
done | 2003-09-06 |
| 122 |
Should the word "characteristically" be added to the scope note of all sub-classes of Appell.... |
3 |
done | 2003-03-25 |
| 123 |
Reclassification needs to be considered .... |
1 |
done | 2003-10-7 |
| 124 |
Scope note for E84 Information Carrier needed.... |
3 |
done | 2002-10-22 |
| 125 |
What notion of semantic interoperability should be contained within the CRM? .... |
3 |
done | 2003-03-25 |
| 126 |
Explanation of Allen Operators.... |
3 |
done | 2007-07-10 |
| 127 |
Properties of E13 Attribute Assignment.... |
1 |
done | 2003-09-17 |
| 128 |
Destruction of features.... |
1 |
done | 2003-09-17 |
| 129 |
Define a comprehensive list of training materials.... |
1 |
done | 2007-07-10 |
| 130 |
FAQ required to deal with availability of the standard. Possible use of core standards. Loca.... |
1 |
done | 2008-05-12 |
| 131 |
Rename P35 has identified (identified by).... |
1 |
done | 2008-05-12 |
| 132 |
Rewrite scope note of E51 Contact Point.... |
1 |
done | 2008-05-12 |
| 133 |
Rewrite scope note of E54 Dimension.... |
1 |
done | 2008-05-12 |
| 134 |
Change scope note of E3 Condition State.... |
1 |
done | 2007-07-10 |
| 135 |
Change scope note of E4 Period.... |
1 |
done | 2007-07-20 |
| 136 |
Change the phrase "This property describes...".... |
1 |
done | 2010-12-20 |
| 137 |
Change example of P1 is identified by (identifies).... |
1 |
done | 2007-07-10 |
| 138 |
Change example of P3 has note.... |
1 |
done | 2007-07-10 |
| 139 |
Change the example of property P5 consists of (forms part of).... |
1 |
done | 2008-11-06 |
| 140 |
Change the domain of P33.... |
1 |
done | 2007-03-14 |
| 141 |
Change the domain of P32.... |
1 |
done | 2007-03-14 |
| 142 |
"P69 is associated with" can be used to describe sequences of procedures.... |
1 |
done | 2007-07-10 |
| 143 |
Revised scope note of E28.... |
1 |
done | 2007-01-12 |
| 144 |
P16 used specific object (was used for) in R26 used constituent (was used in).... |
1 |
done | 2007-07-10 |
| 145 |
shows "how to realise" a plan.... |
1 |
done | 2007-07-10 |
| 146 |
Property P139 has alternative form should have its own "has type" property. .... |
1 |
done | 2008-05-12 |
| 147 |
Check if there is a need for a generalized class to identify usage.... |
1 |
done | 2008-05-12 |
| 148 |
How to model digital image taking or digital recording.... |
1 |
done | 2007-07-10 |
| 149 |
Continue the discussion of 10th SIG meeting about Family relations.... |
1 |
done | 2008-05-12 |
| 150 |
The scope note of E33
.... |
1 |
done | 2008-05-12 |
| 151 |
Specialization of "P1 is identified by" for E75 Conceptual Object Appellation.... |
1 |
done | 2007-07-10 |
| 152 |
Generalization of E30 Right.... |
1 |
done | 2007-07-10 |
| 153 |
Activity without products.... |
1 |
done | 2007_07_11 |
| 154 |
Curation Event.... |
1 |
done | 2008-11-06 |
| 155 |
"Right held" and "is owner".... |
1 |
done | 2008-02-15 |
| 156 |
Measuring activities.... |
1 |
done | 2008-05-13 |
| 157 |
Digitization process .... |
1 |
done | 2008-05-12 |
| 158 |
Intermediate class between E28 Conceptual Object and E73 Information Object .... |
1 |
done | 2008-05-12 |
| 159 |
Constructing appellations .... |
1 |
done | 2008-05-12 |
| 160 |
Bears feature of .... |
1 |
done | 2008-05-12 |
| 161 |
Extensions of the CRM .... |
4 |
open | In Progress |
| 162 |
Continuation of work in CRM .... |
4 |
done | 2010-12-20 |
| 163 |
Super property of R10.... |
4 |
done | 2008-05-13 |
| 164 |
Implementation of Primitive Values .... |
4 |
done | 2011-11-17 |
| 165 |
Scope note of E81.... |
3 |
done | 2010-01-29 |
| 166 |
New class: "Activity Plan" IsA E29 Design or Procedure.... |
1 |
done | 2011-05-18 |
| 167 |
Change the range of P128 carries (is carried by).... |
3 |
done | 2010-12-20 |
| 168 |
Change the first paragraph of the 'Examples' section of the CIDOC CRM
reference document |
3 |
done | 2010-12-20 |
| 169 |
Change the inverse label of E24 : P65 shows visual item (is shown by): E36 Visual Item.... |
3 |
done | 2010-01-29 |
| 170 |
Change the name of P14 carried out by (performed).... |
3 |
done | 2010-01-29 |
| 171 |
Change the name of P44 has condition (condition of).... |
3 |
done | 2010-01-29 |
| 172 |
Temporality of rights.... |
1 |
open | In Progress |
| 173 |
Exchange transactions.... |
1 |
open | In Progress |
| 174 |
Some phrases in the Introduction of the CRM section "Terminology" should be changed.... |
3 |
done | 2010-03-30 |
| 175 |
A phrase in section "Property Quantifiers" of the CIDOC CRM reference document of should b.... |
3 |
done | 2011-05-18 |
| 176 |
A phrase in section "Objectives of the CIDOC CRM" of the CIDOC CRM reference document should.... |
3 |
done | 2011-11-17 |
| 177 |
A phrase in section "Examples" of the CIDOC CRM reference document of should be changed.... |
1 |
done | 2010-05-21 |
| 178 |
P130-superproperty of P128.... |
3 |
done | 2010-12-20 |
| 179 |
A phrase in section "Terminology" of the CIDOC CRM reference document should be changed.... |
1 |
done | 2010-12-20 |
| 180 |
Is a URL really a type of contact point? .... |
3 |
done | 2010-12-20 |
| 181 |
Which are the differences between E31 and E89?.... |
3 |
done | 2010-12-20 |
| 182 |
Missing property from E32 Authority Document to E41 Appellation (or E42 Identifier?).... |
3 |
done | 2011-05-18 |
| 183 |
E75 Conceptual Object Appellation redundant .... |
3 |
done | 2011-05-18 |
| 184 |
Missing explanation of property P69.1 has type.... |
3 |
done | 2011-05-18 |
| 185 |
Missing property declaring the pattern of an identifier assignment.... |
3 |
done | 2010-12-20 |
| 186 |
Phrase in the first example in the introduction of CRM about E53.... |
1 |
done | 2010-12-20 |
| 187 |
The second example in the introduction about E2.... |
1 |
done | 2010-12-20 |
| 188 |
Scope note of E11.... |
1 |
done | 2011-05-18 |
| 189 |
Superproperties for P111, P113, P68.... |
3 |
done | 2010-12-20 |
| 190 |
Scope note of P101.... |
1 |
done | 2010-12-20 |
| 191 |
Range of P31.... |
3 |
open | In Progress |
| 192 |
R14 - P148 - P130.... |
3 |
done | 2011-11-17 |
| 193 |
P109 subp of P49.... |
3 |
done | 2011-11-17 |
| 194 |
P111 subproperty of P16?.... |
3 |
done | 2011-11-17 |
| 195 |
Superproperties of P134, P9,P10.... |
3 |
open | In Progress |
| 196 |
Causation and events.... |
3 |
done | 2011-11-17 |
| 197 |
How to represent imprecision(E60 Number and E61 Time Primitive).... |
3 |
done | 2011-11-17 |
| 198 |
Change Scope note and Example of E32.... |
3 |
done | 2011-11-17 |
| 199 |
"by parent" property.... |
3 |
proposed | In Progress |
| 200 |
Generalization of appellation to CRM.... |
1 |
done | 2012-05-03 |
| 201 |
Inverse P88 consists of (forms part of).... |
3 |
done | 2012-05-03 |
| 202 |
Explanation of "multiple instantiation" concept at the "Disjointness".... |
1 |
open | In Progress |
| 203 |
Identity of Information Objects and incorporate property of FRBRoo.... |
3 |
open | In Progress |
| 204 |
Clarification on scope notes of P50, P52, P55 and explanatory note for temporal validity an.... |
1 |
done | 2012-11-20 |
| 205 |
P65 - P138-P67 guidelines .... |
1 |
open | In Progress |
| 206 |
Generalize appellations in CRM with reference to nomen.... |
3 |
done | 2012-05-03 |
| 207 |
Content of Symbolic Object.... |
1 |
done | 2012-11-20 |
| 208 |
New property for E55 Type about narrower term partitive.... |
3 |
done | 2012-12-20 |
| 209 |
The range of P142 to be changed to E90 Symbolic Object.... |
3 |
done | 2012-11-20 |
| 210 |
New property E66 Formation.Pxx was formed from:E74 Group.... |
3 |
done | 2012-11-20 |
| 211 |
The range 'E19 Physical Object' of the property 'P8 took
place on or within' should be gene.... |
3 |
done | 2012-11-20 |
| 212 |
P62 needs a parent and a sibling.... |
3 |
open | In Progress |
| 213 |
missing property?.... |
3 |
done | 2012-11-20 |
| 214 |
P69 revision.... |
3 |
open | In Progress |
| 215 |
Virtual identities.... |
3 |
open | In Progress |
| 216 |
Continuing Activities.... |
3 |
proposed | 2012-11-20 |
| 218 |
Multiple Instantiation text.... |
3 |
proposed | In Progress |
| 219 |
P88i subproperty of P89.... |
3 |
open | In Progress |
| 220 |
Notion of preferredness.... |
3 |
proposed | In Progress |
| 221 |
Dual events.... |
3 |
proposed | In Progress |
| 222 |
P37, P38, P48 identifiers.... |
3 |
proposed | In Progress |
